212.766.1888

Publications

The Espinal Doctrine

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

Generally, a contractual obligation, standing alone, will not give rise to tort liability in favor of a third party. Eaves Brooks Costume Co. v. Y.B.H. Realty Corp., 76 N.Y.2d 220 (1990). In 1928, Chief Judge Cardozo warned that imposing third-party liability under such circumstances could lead the contracting parties to be liable to “an indefinite number of potential beneficiaries.” Since 1928 several exceptions have arisen to this general rule. The Court of Appeals, in Espinal v. Melville Snow Constrs., 98 N.Y.2d 136 (2002), compiled these exceptions to create what is now known as the “Espinal Doctrine”.

Read More


Governmental Liability For Maintenance of Parks

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

In the early twentieth century, the State of New York had almost complete sovereign immunity from negligence claims. Only those claims specifically allowed by statute could plaintiffs recover against the State. In Smith v. State, 227 NY 405 (1920), the Court held that a plaintiff injured because of the negligence of State employees in placing a wire across a walkway in a state park was barred from recovering because the State had not made an express waiver of the state's immunity from liability for the tortious acts of its officers and agents.

Read More


Video Evidence and the Emergency Doctrine

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal-August 21, 2023

In Pappas v. New York City Transit Authority, 174 N.Y.S.3d 728 (2nd Dept 2022), the Court granted summary judgment to the defendants who submitted surveillance footage in support of their argument that plaintiff’s claim was barred by the emergency doctrine. In recent cases involving the defense of the emergency doctrine, courts have relied on video surveillance in deciding motions for summary judgment. The improvement in camera and video quality and the prevalence of cameras in society have made this a growing trend that will continue and benefit litigants.

Read More


Collateral Estoppel And Its Effect on Workers’ Compensation Decisions

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal-August 7, 2023

Synopsis: Section 118-A of the Worker’s Compensation law recently went into effect on December 30, 2022. It eliminates the collateral estoppel effect of a workers’ compensation board decision in any other action involving the same subject matter that has a prior determination from an administrative board. The exception provided is only for a determination of the existence of an employer/employee relationship.

Read More


The Expansion of Prior Written Notice Protection

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal- July 18, 2023

Synopsis: A municipality that has a prior written notice law cannot be held liable for a defect within the scope of the law unless the requisite written notice has been given. The New York Village law for prior written notice applies to six surfaces and the Town law applies to three. Recently courts have continued to expand the definition to apply to other surfaces that “functionally fulfill the same purpose as a statutory surface.”

Read More


Maldovan: Court of Appeals Declines to Expand Government Liability

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal-March 31, 2023

Synopsis: The Court of Appeals, in Maldovan v. County of Erie, 2022 WL 17095561 [2022], reiterated that the burden necessary to defeat the absolute immunity of a municipality’s agent under the “Special Duty Doctrine” is extremely high.

Read More


Second Dept. Draws the Line for Assumption of Risk in School Sports

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal-​March 10, 2023

Synopsis: Under the assumption of risk doctrine holds that a plaintiff participant is considered to have consented to any risks inherent in their sport or recreational activity. The doctrine has been historically applied in high school sports cases. The defendant school is relieved of the duty to protect the plaintiff from the assumed risks. The key word in the doctrine’s application is the term “inherent.” The Second Department’s latest interpretation of inherency narrows the application of the doctrine.

Read More


“Reckless Disregard” Under VTL § 1103(b) – Hazard Vehicles

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law JournalNovember 23, 2022

Synopsis: Under the VTL, drivers of hazard vehicles engaged in work on highways will not be held liable for injuries caused by their negligence. VTL §1103(b). Drivers of hazard vehicles must be shown to have acted with reckless disregard in order for a court to find them liable. A plaintiff will not recover without demonstrating that the hazard vehicle operator has “intentionally done an act of unreasonable character in disregard of a known or obvious risk that was so great as to make it highly probable that harm would follow . . . with conscious indifference to the outcome.” Saarinen 84 NY2d at 501 (1994). This reckless disregard standard is a heavy burden of proof for plaintiffs.

Read More


Closing Cases Through Intercompany Arbitration

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law JournalOctober 26, 2022

Synopsis: Settling underlying claims and resolving disputed liability or coverage disputes through the Special Arbitration Forums is enormously beneficial to member companies.  It reduces litigation costs, including attorneys’ fees, through faster closings.  The Special Arbitration Forums may be utilized by adjusters without attorneys.  It is simple and easy to use.  In this age of nuclear verdicts, severity is reduced by capping exposure through intercompany arbitration.

Read More


Qualified Immunity: Hazard Vehicles Working on a Highway

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law JournalSeptember 30, 2022

Synopsis: In order for the reckless disregard standard to apply under the VTL §1103 exemption, defendants must be “actually engaged in work on a highway.” Historically courts have interpreted the standard of reckless disregard broadly. When a hazard vehicle is traveling “to or from” work sites, the VTL §1103 exemption does not apply. Additionally, courts have also broadly interpreted what constitutes a “highway” pursuant to the language of the VTL §1103. Recent cases have expanded the limits of what is a hazard vehicle to sanitary vehicles and garbage trucks. This qualified immunity is a powerful tool in the defense of municipalities.

Read More


"Emergency Operations" Under VTL § 1104

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law JournalSeptember 23, 2022

Synopsis: The VTL regulates the operation of vehicles on public highways in the State. A driver whose violation of the VTL causes injury is subject to a basic negligence standard at trial. The driver of an authorized emergency vehicle may instead be held to a recklessness standard, a higher bar for a plaintiff to reach. In order for the driver of an authorized emergency vehicle to be subject to this standard, two requirements must be met. First, the driver must have been acting in one of the manners prescribed by VTL § 1104(b). Second, the driver must have been engaged in an “emergency operation.” The term “emergency operation” is defined in VTL § 114 – b and case law contains broad interpretations in favor of municipalities.

Read More


Proposed Grieving Families Statute Could Have Enormous Impact

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law JournalSeptember 6, 2022

Synopsis: Senate Bill S74A, titled “The Grieving Families Act”, seeks to vastly expand the potential damages available to surviving families in a wrongful death action. It has been passed by the legislature and awaits Governor Hochul’s signature. The proposed statute includes compensation for the following damages: “(iii) grief or anguish caused by the decedent's death, and for any disorder (emphasis added) caused by such grief or anguish; and (iv) loss of love, society, protection, comfort, companionship” The Grieving Families Act, S74A§2(a)(iii-iv). These damages are not presently compensable. Additionally, the proposed statute would extend the current wrongful death statute of limitations from two years to three years and 6 months following the death of the decedent. The Grieving Families Act, S74A§1. Finally, the law, as presently constituted, will take effect immediately upon signing and will apply to all pending and future actions.

Read More


The Key in Ignition Rule: Leaving Your Car Unattended Under VTL § 1210(a)

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law JournalAugust 4, 2022

Synopsis: VTL § 1210(a) requires vehicle owners to do four things before leaving their car unattended: stop the engine, lock the ignition, remove the key from the vehicle, and set the brake. This does not require the removal of keys that are in the car for convenience or safety. The vehicle owner need only ensure that the key is hidden from plain sight such that a person could not easily spot it while passing by. If these precautions are not taken, the vehicle owner could be found liable for damages caused by the driver while operating the stolen vehicle under VTL § 388.

This provision applies upon public highways, private roads open to public motor vehicle traffic, and any other parking lot. It is not applicable to one’s private property, such as a homeowner’s driveway or a company’s private parking lot. Common sense tells us that it is advisable to remove keys and key fobs whenever a vehicle is left unattended, but since common sense is not so common, we have these cases to discuss.

Read More


Shifting Gears: Updating New York VTL §388 and Restoring Protection for Vehicle Owners

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - July 21, 2022

Synopsis: VTL §388 holds vehicle owners accountable and ensures that victims of accidents involving a vehicle owned by a person but driven by a non-owner could seek financial redress for their injuries. Recent applications of VTL §388 by New York Courts have protected owners from liability where their vehicles are clearly used without their consent.

Read More


Alternative Vehicles: What Is Legal And What Is Not?

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - July 7, 2022

Synopsis: Alternative vehicle use is rapidly increasing in the City. A violation of a State statute constitutes negligence per se, while a violation of a City rule is only “some evidence of negligence.” Thorough review of the New York State Vehicle and Traffic Law and the Rules and Administrative Code of the City of New York is imperative in representing a plaintiff or a defendant in cases involving alternative vehicles.

Read More


Sidewalk Update: New York City Administrative Code § 7-210

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal - March 15, 2022

Synopsis: This article takes look at several cases which address the issue of liability for sidewalk maintenance. The authors conclude that “the purpose underlying the enactment of the exemption in New York City Administrative Code §7-210 is to promote the safety of pedestrians making use of public walkways. Imposing a duty upon owners of real property to maintain the sidewalk abutting their property incentivizes the maintenance of sidewalks and creates safer walkways for pedestrians.”

Read More


Premeditated Criminal Acts and Landowner Liability

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - September 17, 2021

Synopsis: There has been a recent split between the First and Second Department as to treatment of landowner liability for the premeditated criminal acts of other parties. While the First Department has reiterated the spontaneity standard, whereas the Second Department found that a landowner’s negligence could be a concurrent factor in even premeditated crimes. This split will likely be addressed before the Court of Appeals in the near future.

Read More


Security Guard Liability in New York

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - September 3, 2021

Synopsis: Security guards and companies are particularly vulnerable to liability due to the nature of their work. However, New York law imposes a significant bar to liability except where the security personnel assume a duty, act outside of the scope of their security work, or were negligently hired or trained.

Read More



“Serious Injury” Update

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal -  August 30, 2021

Synopsis: Cases recently decided by the Appellate Division have indicated a shift toward reducing the scope of what is considered a serious injury pursuant to New York Insurance Law § 5102(d). Such decisions have generally more closely adhered to the letter and legislative intent of the law, finding a lack of serious injury where evidence failed to clearly demonstrate the existence of such injury under the law.

Read More


Residential Landowner’s Liability for Third Party Criminal Acts

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal -  August 21, 2021

Synopsis: A landowner is required to take minimal precautions to protect guests and residents on its premises from criminal conduct, particularly where there is evidence of significant similar criminal acts occurring within a reasonable proximity. However, precedent holds that a landowner will not be held liable for the premeditated criminal acts of third parties.

Read More


Understanding New York’s “Zone of Danger” Rule in Non-Automobile Situations

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal -  August 11, 2021

Synopsis: While often applied to automobile accidents, New York’s “Zone of Danger” theory related to actions for emotional distress has broader applications. The court’s highly fact-specific and narrow precedent, however, make it a difficult burden for a plaintiff to meet.

Read More


Second Dept. Takes Charge: The Burden of Excluding Third-Party Observers

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - February 26, 2021

Synopsis: Eliminating ambiguity created in the First and Fourth Departments, the Second Department places the burden squarely on defendants for the exclusion of ‘IME Watchdogs.’

Read More


‘Greene’: Court of Appeals Narrowly Expands Recovery for Emotional Harm

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - February 23, 2021

Synopsis: The ‘Greene’ decision is extraordinary in its narrow application. It results in the addition of grandparents to the “definition of immediate family” who may recover if they are in the zone of danger and witness the unspeakable horror of having a grandchild die before their eyes.

Read More


Dram Shop Act: Boats, Motorcycles, ATVs, and Snowmobiles

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – February 3, 2021

Synopsis: New York’s Dram Shop Act makes it illegal for commercial vendors to serve alcohol to persons, who are “visibly intoxicated” or under the age of 21. The majority of cases arise when an intoxicated patron leaves the establishment in a car and causes an accident. Liability is not limited, however, to accidents involving cars but has been extended to include boats, motorcycles, ATVs, and snowmobiles.

Read More


NY Labor Law §240: What Is a ‘Structure’?

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – November 17, 2020

Synopsis: Labor Law §240 was enacted in response to the Legislature’s concern over unsafe conditions for employees who worked at height-related worksites. When assessing §240 claims in New York, parties should be aware that courts interpret the word “structure” liberally and that the word itself can manifest in a multitude of ways. This article highlights some surprising examples.

Read More


The Virtual Jury Trial: Concerns and Considerations in Conducting Remote Trials

By Kevin G. Faley and Robert S. Whitbeck

Newsletter of the Federation of Defense and Corporation Counsel - November 6, 2020

Synopsis: While the concept of a virtual jury trial in the pre-pandemic world seemed like an extremely unlikely concept, the idea is now one attorneys may need to consider. Trying cases through this virtual medium would require attorneys to re-shape many of the very tenets of trial practice.

Read More


Snow and Ice Cases: Storm in Progress Doctrine

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

The Journal of the Defense Association of New York

November 2020

 

Synopsis: A review of the storm in progress doctrine and its applicability to premises liability cases

 

Read More


 

The Dram Shop Act: An Update

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – October 24, 2020

 

Synopsis: Dram Shop liability arises out of a vendor’s duty to the public not to sell liquor to visibly intoxicated people, so while legislation seeks to shift some responsibility to alcohol providers, violations are often difficult to prove.

 

Read More


 

Damages for Wrongful Death and Survivorship: Two Distinct Causes of Action

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal September 15, 2020

 

Synopsis: To recover damages for a person’s death in New York State, there are two distinct causes of action: survivorship and wrongful death. Attorneys must be familiar with what is and is not recoverable under each.

 

Read More


 

A Closer Look at Qualified Immunity

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal July 23, 2020

Synopsis: Following the murder of George Floyd, nationwide protests erupted, demanding the elimination of the qualified immunity doctrine. Although new legislation has been introduced to end the qualified immunity doctrine, legislatures should proceed with caution before eradicating the immunity.

 

Read More


 

Going Where Experts Can’t: Viability and Admissibility Issues For Firms and Experts Relying Upon Drone-Obtained Evidence

By Kevin G. Faley and Robert S. Whitbeck

Newsletter of the Federation of Defense and Corporation Counsel March 2020

Synopsis: Drone use in the context of legal investigations and evidence collection must be considered as this technology becomes more prevalent. The practicality, legality, and admissibility of this type of evidence pose questions which have largely not yet been addressed by the courts.

 

Read More


 

Interest and Excess Verdicts

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal January 23, 2020

Synopsis: The question of when interest begins to run in a case where the jury has rendered a verdict in excess of the available policies of insurance is a complicated one.

 

Read More


 

Offer of Judgment: An Underutilized Tool in Federal Cases

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal December 23, 2019

Synopsis: An offer of judgment is used to encourage settlements and protect parties willing to settle early in the litigation process. It is an extremely useful tool however there are important nuances to using this strategy successfully.

 

Read More


 

A Jury Verdict” Now What?”

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal December 13, 2019

Synopsis: There are numerous post-trial motions that one can utilize under the CPLR when faced with an unfavorable verdict.

 

Read More


 

‘High -Low’ Settlements: Insurance Against Bad Faith Claims

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal  November 21, 2019

Synopsis: In this new era of personal injury “nuclear verdicts” that far exceed policy limits, insurance companies are searching for protection. The underutilized offer of a “high-low” agreement provides that protection.

 

Read More


 

“Rosa”: ‘Causally Related’ Is Insufficient To Establish Serious injury

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal October 24, 2019

Synopsis: The rule of 'Rosa' and its progeny as interpreted by the trial courts is that mere medical pronouncement that injuries are causally related to the accident is not enough to create an issue of fact to defeat summary judgment.

 

Read More


 

NY Court of Appeals Continues to Expand Prior Written Notice Protections for Municipalities

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal June 10, 2019

Synopsis: The high court continues to expand coverage of N.Y. Gen. Mun. Law §50-e(4), and give protection to municipal entities throughout the state.

 

Read More


 

Back to the Future” Stunning Reversal in IME “Watchdogs” Case Leaves Obscurity in Discovery Demands

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – May 10, 2019

Synopsis: While the First Department has attempted to bring clarity to the issue by rendering its decision, the Second Department has yet to deliver a decision on the issue.

Read More


 

Is PTSD a 'Serious Injury' Under Insurance Law §5102(d)?

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – April 8, 2019

Synopsis: The Third and Fourth Departments have begun to consider post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as a ‘serious injury’ under Insurance Law §5102(d)’s definition of “significant limitation of use of a body function or system.” Currently, the First and Second Departments have not followed suit.

 

Read More


 

False Arrest/False Imprisonment and Late Notice of Claims

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – November 29, 2018

Synopsis: The factors to be considered in determining whether to grant leave to file a late notice of claim for false arrest and false imprisonment claims. 

 

Read More


 

The Intersect of Bankruptcy and Personal Injury

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – November 21, 2018

Synopsis: The effect of failing to disclose a personal injury claim as an asset in a bankruptcy proceeding.  

 

Read More


 

The Application of Labor Law §240(1) to Accidents Involving Ramps

By Kevin G. Faley and Lina C. Rossillo

The Journal of the Defense Association of New York – Winter 2018

Synopsis: are falls from ramps afforded protections under Labor Law § 240(1)? 

 

Read More


 

Calculating Loss of Future Earnings

By Kevin G. Faley and Lina C. Rossillo

New York Law Journal – December 27, 2017

Synopsis: A review of the factors that are considered in calculating future loss of earnings.

 

Read More


 

Crisis Handling in Municipal Cases

By Andrea Alonso and Kenneth Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – November 28, 2017

Synopsis: A review of methods a municipal entity should employ in order to handle high profile crises that may result in litigation.

 

Read More


 

The Role of Patient Advocates at an Independent Medical Examination

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – October 27, 2017

Synopsis: A review of the role of a patient advocate at an independent medical examination and the difference in approach of the First Department and Second Department in determining whether an patient advocate should be present.

 

Read More


Update on ‘Serious Injury’

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – October 2, 2017

Synopsis: A review of ‘serious injury’ and the need for contemporaneous medical reports as proof of causation.

 

Read More


Capacity of Infants to Testify

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley,

New York Law Journal – September 7, 2017

Synopsis: A review of the method of determining an infant’s capacity to testify.

 

Read More


 

Consent, I Presume? VTL § 388 and Permissive Use

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – August 8, 2017

Synopsis: An analysis of the high burden that must be met to rebut the presumption of consent established by VTL § 388

 

Read More


 

Settlement Techniques High-Low Agreements

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – July 26, 2017

Synopsis: A discussion of high-low agreements and the benefits of its use to plaintiffs and defendants.

 

Read More


 

The ‘Creation Exception’ to the Pothole Law: Difficult to Prove

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – June 13, 2017

Synopsis: A review of the immediate creation exception as a means of circumventing the prior written notice requirement.

 

Read More


 

The Elevation of the Expert

By: Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – May 25, 2017

Synopsis: The use of expert opinions to determine the adequacy of safety devices under Labor Law §240(1).

 

Read More


 

Proprietary Capacity and Substantial Prejudice in Municipal Liability Cases

By: Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – April 14, 2017

Synopsis: An analysis of two significant Court of Appeals cases in the area of Municipal Law

 

Read More


 

Traumatic Brain Injury as a 'Grave Injury': An Examination of 'Rubeis' and Its Progeny

By: Kevin G. Faley and Christopher R. Invidiata

New York Law Journal – March 31, 2017

Synopsis: A discussion of the grave injury threshold of the Worker’s Compensation Law and traumatic brain injury.

 

Read More


 

Louis D. Brandeis: American Prophet

By Andrea Alonso

New York Law Journal – October 24, 2016

Synopsis: A review of the book by Jeffrey Rosen.

 

Read More


 

Hazard Vehicles: When Does Reckless Disregard Standard Apply?

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – September 7, 2016

Synopsis: A review of the expanded protections afforded to hazard vehicles under New York Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL) § 1103.

 

Read More


 

Liability and Emergency Responders: a U-Turn Around 'Kabir'

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – July 15, 2016

Synopsis: In 2011, the Court of Appeals drastically undercut the protection afforded to emergency responders under New York Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL) § 1104. '

 

Read More


 

When Same-Sex Harassment Creates a Hostile Work Environment

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – June 2, 2016

Synopsis: A review of the current standards for same-sex harassment claims.

 

Read More


Insurance Claims Files: How Privileged Are They?

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – April 29, 2016

Synopsis: A discussion on privilege regarding insurers’ claims files during discovery in first-party and third-party litigation.

 

Read More


 

Proper Objections at a Personal Injury Deposition

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – March 21, 2016

Synopsis: There are four main categories of questions at a deposition which an attorney can instruct his client not to answer

 

Read More


Priority of Insurance in Construction Accidents

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – February 18, 2016

Synopsis: A discussion on how to determine the priority of insurance in construction accident cases

 

Read More


 

Pope's New Rule on Annulment: Will the Law Keep Up?

By Andrea M. Alonso & Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal - December 18, 2015

Synopsis: A review of New York Domestic Relations Law Section 253 and its applicability to Jewish and Catholic religious divorces.

 

Read more


 

Notorious R.B.G.: The Life and Times of Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Book Review By Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal - November 30, 2015

Synopsis: A review of the book by Irin Carmon and Shana Knizhnik

 

Read More


 

Timing of Expert Disclosure Under CPLR 3101(d)

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – April 21, 2015

Synopsis: A review of relevant decisions leads to the conclusion that neither the First nor Second Department seems inclined to draw a "bright-line" rule on whether expert disclosure after the Note of Issue and Certificate of Readiness have been filed is considered untimely.

 

Read More


 

Uber: Does New Ticket to Ride Carry Personal Risks?

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – March 4, 2015

Synopsis: A discussion of the insurance requirements, ride-sharing protocol, surge pricing and other issues that have emerged with the rise in new “ride-sharing” car services such as Uber.

 

Read More


 

 

The Missing Witness Charge: A Powerful Tool for Trial

By Kevin G. Faley and Rebecca Rosedale

Defendant – Winter 2015 – Vol. 15 – No.2

Synopsis: The missing witness charge is an important tool at trial.  In New York, there are four preconditions that must be satisfied prior to a jury receiving this charge. 

 

Read More


 

 

10 Timeless Rules for a Defense Practice

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea Alonso

Defendant – Winter 2015 – Vol. 15 – No.2

Synopsis: Ten tips for the successful practice of insurance defense from John E. Morris, the founding partner of Morris Duffy Alonso Faley & Pitcoff.

 

Read More


 

The Erosion of the 'One Bite' Rule

By Kevin G. Faley

NYSBA Torts, Insurance & Compensation Law Section Journal – Fall 2014 – Vol. 43 – No.1

Synopsis: The Court of Appeals has recently deviated from its long held common-law principles of liability and held that an owner of a domestic animal can be liable under ordinary negligence principals.

 

Read More

 

Tort Liability When Bystanders Are in the ‘Zone of Danger’

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – August 27, 2014

Synopsis: In New York, the general rule is that bystanders cannot assert a claim for negligent infliction of emotional distress. However, New York recognizes an exception to this principle: the "zone of danger" rule, which is commonly associated with automobile accidents, but has been applied in cases involving house fires, assaults and elevator accidents.

 

Read More

 

 

How to Respond to Politically Incorrect Comments in a Professional Setting

By Andrea M. Alonso

*Originally published in the DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar- May 22, 2014

Synopsis: As attorneys, we will find ourselves in uncomfortable situations when clients make racist, sexist or politically inappropriate comments in our presence. How does an attorney respond? Typically these comments are made over the phone where the client has not met the attorney in person. Sometimes they are made in a face to face conversation where the client makes an incorrect assumption about the attorney's ethnicity, sexual orientation, religion or political views. Often times the person who uttered the incorrect and thoughtless remarks are crucial to the attorney's practice.

 

Read More

 

 

Sun Glare and the Emergency Doctrine in Auto Cases

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – May 20, 2014

Synopsis: A discussion of the development of the emergency doctrine prior to the Court of Appeals holding in 'Lifson v. City of Syracuse,' the decision, and how courts are still applying the emergency charge in new and often unique situations.

 

Read More

 

 

Dram Shop Update: Extent of Liability for Serving Liquor

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – March 13, 2014

Synopsis: Recently, courts in New York have been limiting the extent of personal liability for injuries that result from another's intoxication, but upholding stricter rules on the public taverns and commercial establishments that serve alcohol.

Read More

 

 

Conversion in the Electronic Age

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – January 21, 2014

Synopsis: The American legal system has struggled in applying obsolete concepts to modern legal dilemmas. An example of this is conversion, a theory of recovery which, until recently, substantiated our society's reluctance to either adapt antiquated claims to the 21st century or discard these archaic concepts to the ash heap of history. While recently some jurisdictions have recognized conversion's applicability to intangible property, others have been hesitant to adopt that approach.

Read More

 

 

Health Club Liability: Work Out The Law Before You Get Physical

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – December 11, 2013

Synopsis: A discussion of caselaw related to health clubs, gyms and other fitness centers, including the recent Court of Appeals holding on the use of automated external defibrillators, a health club's duty as a landowner, membership contracts and the assumption of risk doctrine.

Read More

 

 

‘Kabir’ Update: ‘Worst Fears’ Realized Prompts Proposed Amendments

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – September 4, 2013

Synopsis: In a post-'Kabir' world, emergency responders face a precedent that fosters perverse incentives. It encourages responders to violate the rules of the road in order to gain the higher burden of proof of reckless disregard, and denies the same protection to those who obey them. New bills aim to restore Vehicle and Traffic Law §1104's initial intent.

Read More

 

 

Diversity at the Interview – How to Approach It

By Andrea M. Alonso

*Originally published in the DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar– February 11, 2013

Synopsis: Diversity in American law firms is woefully inadequate. The Association for Legal Career Professionals reports at the associate level only 4.29% of all associates are African American with 2.61% being women. Numbers of Hispanic associates lag behind. Associates total 3.83% with women making up only 1.9%. The statistics are much worse for partners. African American partners only constitute 1.71% of partners with women representing .58%. Hispanic partners are 1.92% of the population with women only making up .48% of partners. Women and Minorities in Law Firms – By Race and Ethnicity, NALP BULLETIN (Jan. 2012), available at http://www.nalp.org/race_ethn_jan2010.

Read More

 

 

Municipal Liability for Property Damage Cause by Flooding

By Andrea M. Alonso and Carl S. Sandel

New York Law Journal – September 24, 2012

Synopsis: The aftermath of Hurricane Irene in 2011 has given rise to a substantial increase in the number of lawsuits seeking to hold municipalities liable for property damage caused by flooding.

Read More

 

 

‘Kabir’ and Its Progeny: A Reckless Disregard for Common Sense

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – August 1, 2012

Synopsis: It appears as if the 'Kabir' decision has changed emergency vehicle litigation by encouraging emergency responders to act with the type of reckless disregard that the statute once used as a shield from liability for their municipal employers.

Read More

 

 

Pattern Jury Instructions and Premises Liability

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – June 11, 2012

Synopsis: Given the breadth of scenarios covered by the PJI, there is likely to be a relevant charge in most premises liability cases.

Read More

 

 

Car vs. Bike: Rules of the Road

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – December 13, 2011

Synopsis: In any personal injury action, knowledge of applicable statutes and case law is crucial to competent handling of the matter. As more individuals look for ways to economize, bicycles are becoming a more popular mode of transportation. Bicyclists are subject to most of the same duties as motor vehicles, as well as many other statutory requirements, which could result in a jury charge of negligence per se against a cyclist.

Read More

 

 

Court of Appeals Holds That Conditions Involving Snow or Ice Need Not Be Immediately Created in Order to Hold a Municipality Liable Under the Affirmative Creation Exception to the Prior Written Notice Rule

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

NYSBA Torts, Insurance & Compensation Law Section Journal – Winter 2011 – Vol. 40 – No.2

Synopsis: An analysis of the ruling in San Marco v. Village of Mount Kisco, which addressed the exceptions through which a municipality can be held liable for injuries stemming from an allegedly dangerous and/or defective street or sidewalk condition.

Read More

 

 

Groninger v. Village of Mamaroneck: Prior Written Notice Laws Are Applicable to Municipal Parking Lots

By Kenneth E. Pitcoff and Anna J. Ervolina

NYSBA Torts, Insurance & Compensation Law Section Journal – Winter 2011 – Vol. 40 – No.2

Synopsis: A discussion of the significant win for every municipality in New York State with Groninger v. Village of Mamaroneck. The Court of Appeals held that municipalities are entitled to prior written notice of defects located within municipally owned parking lots.

Read More

 

 

Spoliation of Evidence: Considerations and Remedies

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – July 25, 2011

Synopsis: The courts consider a broad range of factors in deciding when and what spoliation remedies are appropriate, and at the very least, there must be a duty to preserve evidence in order to sustain a spoliation claim and the court will then ask if the evidence is essential to the case and whether either party is prejudiced without it.

 

Failure to Provide Police Protection and Special Relationship Exception

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – April 8, 2011

Synopsis: The special relationship exception is a narrow one and the New York courts require a plaintiff to prove four elements to determine whether or not such relationship exists between the police and the injured person, the last of which, justifiable reliance on the municipality's affirmative undertaking to act on behalf of the injured party, has been the most difficult for a plaintiff to prove.

Read More

 

 

Pattern Jury Instructions and Automobile Accidents

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – December 27, 2010

Synopsis: Given the breadth of scenarios covered by the PJI, there is likely to be a relevant charge in most automobile accident cases.

Read More

 

 

State High Court Tweaks Additional Insurance Coverage

By Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – September 7, 2010

Synopsis: A refresher on the Court of Appeals position on what triggers additional insurance coverage.

Read More

 

 

Motorcycle Litigation: No Easy Ride

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – September 3, 2010

Synopsis: A review of motorcycle law, including insurance coverage, traffic regulations, passenger rules, limited use motorcycle classifications and other statutes that may come into play in a personal injury action.

Read More

 

 

Classifying and Expanding Protected Activities Under Labor Law 240(1)

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – June 9, 2010

Synopsis: No court has developed a set formula to ascertain whether or not an activity is protected under the Labor Law. The consensus both from the Court of Appeals and the Appellate Divisions, they say, is that inspections are not protected if merely incidental to a protected activity.

Read More

 


 

The Gravity of the Labor Law

 By Kevin G. Faley

 New York Law Journal – February 22, 2010

Synopsis: Over the years, the Court of Appeals and the appellate divisions have dealt with thousands of claims invoking the protection of Labor Law §240(1). As the courts examine these very fact-driven cases against the backdrop of this well-worn statute, they have created not a bright line rule on what is or is not a 240(1) claim, but rather a line of varying shades of gray. 

Read More

 

 

Recovering Damages for Death: Two Separate Causes of Action

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – February 1, 2010

Synopsis: Death cases in New York are frequently not evaluated properly by claims representatives and attorneys alike.

Read More


New York City Traffic Regulations As ‘Some Evidence’ of Negligence

 By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

 New York Law Journal – December 2, 2009

 Synopsis: The New York City Traffic Regulations run the gamut from basic prohibitions ("No person shall operate a vehicle in a manner that will endanger any person or property;" "No person shall sound the horn of a vehicle except when necessary to warn a person or animal of danger") to the enumeration of the 30-plus holidays on which street cleaning rules are suspended. It is important, they advise, that the practitioner in any automobile case scour the regulations to obtain a jury charge in her client's favor.

Read More

 

 

Tightening the Labor Law: Falling Objects and §240(1)

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – October 1, 2009

 Synopsis: While courts are certainly protective of a worker's rights under the Labor Law, they have simultaneously recognized that owners and contractors are not insurers and cannot be held responsible for each and every injury suffered at a work site. The courts have resolved these two views, they say, by limiting the application of this safe workplace statute to only those hazards specifically contemplated by the statute and also by questioning the somewhat sacrosanct belief that workers cannot protect themselves from work-site dangers. 

Read More

 

 

Broadening of the Recalcitrant Worker Defense in Labor Law Actions

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

 New York Law Journal –  July 24, 2009

 Synopsis: The recalcitrant worker defense, one of the few defenses available to owners and general contractors when a worker has been injured in a gravity-related accident. In the past, this affirmative defense required a defendant to prove that the injured worker refused to use an available safety device after being specifically and immediately instructed to do so and that this refusal proximately caused the accident. In a recent line of cases, however, courts across New York State have begun to broaden the applicability of this defense, holding workers responsible, at least to a certain extent, for their own safety.

Read More

 

 

 Wage Recovery for Illegal Aliens in New York Under the Labor Law

 By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

 New York Law Journal – May 26, 2009

 Synopsis: While the Federal Immigration Reform and Control Act was intended to curtail illegal immigration and the employment of illegal aliens, it remained undecided whether it should preempt the Labor Law and, ultimately, bar an illegal alien from receiving lost wages for injuries sustained on the job. With the question of illegal immigration unresolved on the national scale, the New York courts appear to have carved out their own rule.

Read More

 

 

Insurance Policy Exclusions and Construction Projects

By Kevin G. Faley and Anna J. Ervolina 

New York Law Journal – September 30, 2008

Synopsis: An insurance company's decision to deny coverage to its insured is not generally favored by the courts. However two recent decisions from the Second Department signify a change in the willingness to validate an denial of coverage. In each case, the insurance company successfully enforced a carefully worded exclusion contained in its policy which left contractors without insurance for a construction accident.

Read More

 

 

CPLR §1601: Limiting Liability Against Public Entities?

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

 New York Law Journal – March 24, 2008

Synopsis: several bills are currently before the New York State Assembly that propose enlarging the benefits of CPLR Article 16 as it relates to public entities.  Essentially, the statute holds a defendant responsible only for its actual share of damages if its degree of culpability was found by the jury to be 50 percent or less.

Read More

 

 

New Definition of ‘Creation Exception’ to Pothole Law

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kenneth Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – March 6, 2007

Synopsis: The  First and Second departments have recently narrowed the "creation exemption" to the Prior Written Notice Statute as it applies to roadwork to require proof that the alleged negligent prior repair immediately resulted in the existence of a dangerous condition.

Read More

 

 

Marked Ready for Trial: An Insurance Professional’s Guide to Pre-Trial Preparation

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

Claims – November 2006

Synopsis: The process is described from the moment a company learns of a potential lawsuit and continues through discovery and the actual trial.

Read More

 

 

Proposed Amendments to the Recreational Use Statute

By Kevin G. Faley and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – September 25, 2006

Synopsis: Approximately 85 percent of New York State is privately owned. Many outdoor recreationalists rely on the magnanimity of private landowners to meet their need for land use. Landowners are more likely to welcome these individuals onto their land if they are confident that they are protected from liability.

Read More

 

 

Insurance Coverage Issues Involving Pocket Bikes

By Kevin G. Faley and Pauline E. Glaser

The Journal of the Defense Association of New York – Fall 2005/Winter 2006

Synopsis: The article discusses the complex insurance coverage implications of pocket bikes.

Read More

 

 

The Effect of Spousal Immunity on Car Insurance Coverage

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – October 27, 2005

Synopsis: A review of Insurance Law §3420(g), which protects insurance carriers from collusive spousal actions by holding that they are generally not obligated to defend or indemnify an insured from claims because of injuries to the spouse, a policy that has caused confusion in the courts and amongst automobile insurance holders.

Read More

 

 

Security Guard Liability

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – August 5, 2005

Synopsis: Potential liability arises for assault and battery, which may occur during the course of attempting to stop or arrest a suspected shoplifter, and for subsequent false-imprisonment claims by the detainee. Liability, in exceptional circumstances, may also arise from the failure of a security guard to protect patrons.

Read More

 

 

The Erosion of the “Integral and Necessary” Standard Under the Labor Law

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

The Defendant – Spring 2005

Synopsis: The article discusses how the “integral and necessary” test has diminished as a result of resent case law.

Read More

 

 

Liability Exemptions for Emergency Vehicles

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kenneth E. Pitcoff

New York Law Journal – May 3, 2005

Synopsis: The reasonableness of the operator of an emergency vehicle's conduct must be gauged at the time and under the circumstances in which he acted, not in retrospect.

Read More

 

 

Commercial Owner’s Liability for Assaults Between Patrons

 By Kevin G. Faley and Richard J. Gallo

New York Law Journal – March 17, 2005

Synopsis: Contrary to the pervasive belief in the underwriting community, it is actually difficult to hold owners of public establishments liable for unanticipated assaults among patrons that occur on their premises. The liability for such incidents is quite circumscribed in New York.

Read More

 

 

Postscript: Head Injuries, Workers’ Compensation Law After ‘Rubeis’

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – January 27, 2005

Synopsis: The Court of Appeals has adopted the "employability" standard rather than the "self-care" standard and defined permanent total disability as being "when the evidence establishes that the injured worker is no longer employable in any capacity."

Read More

 

 

“Close Those Files or Else!” The Need for Case Resolution Planning

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

The Brief – Spring 2005

Synopsis: The pressures of closing case files can be problematic for claims attorneys. The need for an understanding partnership between the defense attorney and the insurance company is imperative to develop a precise method to effectively close case files.

Read More

 

 

Head Injuries and Worker’s’ Compensation Law

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York Law Journal – September 24, 2004

Synopsis: The employer funding of New York's Workers' Compensation system was intended to limit recovery for an injured employee to Workers' Compensation benefits. But the purpose of the system is sometimes evaded through impleader actions wherein employers were sued as third-party defendants.

Read More

 

 

The Changing Insurance Defense Climate: Law Firm Survival

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

For the Defense – August 2000

Synopsis: The changes in the insurance defense industry require firm to adjust and evolve  to maintain a successful business structure.

Read More

 

 

A Claims Professional’s Bill of Rights

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

Claims – November 1999

Synopsis: A discussion of the change in the relationship with insurance companies and outside counsel. The basic services that outside counsel should provide to claims professionals on any property or casualty claim are highlighted.

Read More

 

 

Interviewing for a Job at an Insurance Defense Firm

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

For the Defense – January 1999

Synopsis: A guideline for interviewing at insurance defense firms. Items such as preparation for the interview, dress code, the interview discussion and the close of the interview are addressed.

Read More

 

 

Proximate Cause of Negligent Security Cases: The Predicted Effects of Burgos and Gomez

By Michael B. Titowsky

Torts, Insurance & Compensation Law Journal – Spring 1999

Synopsis: A discussion of two Court of Appeals cases involving landlord-tenant security measures and injuries.

Read More

 

 

There are No Bad Dogs: Recent Ruling in Dog Bite Cases

By Kevin G. Faley, Andrea M. Alonso, and Pamela A. Smith

Defendant – Spring 1999

Synopsis: The state of law regarding dog bite cases in New York is analyzed. Case law evolution in the state is presented and the various intricacies of laws in place to address the actions.

Read More

 

 

Outside Counsel: Applying the 1996 Three-Year Limit in Professional Malpractice Case

By Kevin G. Faley and Andrea M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – February 22, 1999

Synopsis: The New York State Legislature amended the CPLR Section 214(6) effective September 4, 1996 to repeal the rule enunciated by the Court of Appeals in Santulli v. Englert, Reilly & McHugh, P.C. that the statute of limitations to be applied in actions for professional malpractice (other than medical, dental or podiatric) is not solely the three year negligence limitation.

Read More

 

An Offer You Can’t Refuse – A Proposal for a New State Offer of Judgment Rule

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

New York State Bar Journal – March/April 1998

Synopsis: A comparison of New York and Florida state statutes involving offer of judgment procedures. The New York Offer of Judgment Rule’s effect on settlements and frivolous litigations is also discussed.

Read More

 

 

The Law Firm Culture of Abuse

By Andrea M. Alonso and Kevin G. Faley

ABA Journal – March 27, 1998

Synopsis: Trends in the legal field involving senior supervising attorneys belittling young associates are discussed. The law firm culture of abuse is a problem that must be eliminated to decrease the number of young attorneys who change jobs early in their careers.

Read More

 

 

High Low Agreements: Misunderstood Litigation Technique

By Kevin G. Faley and Andre M. Alonso

New York Law Journal – March 27, 1998

Synopsis: The litigation technique of high-low agreements is underutilized and misunderstood during the trial of tort cases. Benefits of the strategy for both sides of the litigation are

Read More



© 2024 Morris Duffy Alonso Faley & Pitcoff | Disclaimer
Attorneys | Publications | Practice Areas | Verdicts | Appeals | About | Newsletters | Decisions

-
-